For Immediate Release April 25, 2002 POLITICAL PARTIES WRONG TO APPEAL BLANKET PRIMARY DECISION The Washington State Grange condemned the Democratic, Republican and Libertarian parties' decision to appeal the March 27 ruling of Federal District Court Judge Franklin D. Burgess that upheld Washington's popular blanket primary. "We don't understand why the parties insist on pursuing this unpopular and futile effort to change our primary system," said State Grange President Terry Hunt, "The people of the state want the right to choose their own candidates." The political parties appealed Judge Burgess' decision to the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in San Francisco. State Grange attorney Jim Johnson said, "We are confident of a win in this appeal. With this defeat, it will be 'three strikes and you're out' for the political parties." The blanket primary withstood two previous challenges in the Washington state Supreme Court, one in 1936 and the other in 1980. The Washington State Grange wrote the original blanket primary initiative in 1934 and it was adopted by the State Legislature the following year. Attorneys representing the Washington Secretary of State and the Grange argued in favor of the constitutionality of the blanket primary in federal district court last month. The Democratic, Republican, and Libertarian parties sought to overturn Washington's primary election system after a U.S. Supreme Court decision in 2000 found California's blanket primary unconstitutional. As the Grange pointed out in federal district court, California's "open" primary differed from Washington's blanket primary because Washington does not require voters to register by party affiliation. Judge Burgess agreed with the Grange, ruling that the political parties failed to prove any injury to their right of association. Eliminating the blanket primary would likely cause a fall in voter turnout. California's primary election turnout dropped to its lowest level in history when its open blanket primary was replaced with a closed, party-based system last year. "Washington must preserve the rights of its citizens to vote for any candidate in the primary. We can be a model for other states who want to give primary elections back to the people," said Hunt. ####
